Building community through nonprofits with James Young

5/6/2025

It’s natural to be in rooms with people that we agree with or get along with who have similar personalities that tends to correlate with socioeconomic status, it tends to correlate with race.

So we self sort and we’re really good at what Putnam calls bonding capital. So it’s like creating groups of me and my conservative friends have a particular issue and we think it’s important that we create a local neighborhood coalition around this particular issue. And we’ll call that school safety.

And then you say, Oh, there’s some opportunities there to cross some boundaries. I think everyone cares about school safety. There’s a, [00:15:00] there’s a kernel of shared interest in there, but in and of itself, if you stay in your lane and you just have that conversation with these like minded people, that’s called bonding capital.
— James Young

In episode 122 of Mission: Impact, Carol Hamilton and James Young discuss the role of community, social innovation, and problem-solving in nonprofit leadership. They explore 

  • how organizations can foster meaningful collaboration, 

  • move beyond traditional silos, and embrace an interdisciplinary approach to tackling complex challenges. 

  • the importance of balancing expertise with curiosity, 

  • strengthening both bonding and bridging social capital, and designing intentional community experiences that drive impact. 

Together, they reflect on how associations and nonprofits can evolve to meet the shifting needs of their members and society at large.

Episode highlights:

[00:09:45] Social Innovation as a Driving Force

  • the interplay between challenge and learning through community-driven problem-solving.

[00:012:00] Navigating Uncertainty While Staying Grounded in Mission

  • the difficulty of focusing on nonprofit work amidst larger societal challenges.

  • the importance of coalition-building and fostering social connections in times of division.

[00:13:22] Learning Communities and Interdisciplinary Problem-Solving

  • the importance of approaching problems with both expertise and a beginner’s mindset to foster innovation.

[00:16:48] The Role of Expertise and Curiosity in Leadership

  • A discussion on the balance between valuing deep expertise and welcoming fresh perspectives that challenge assumptions.

  • a model for fostering collaborative problem-solving.

[00:19:08] The Messiness of Community and Building Trust

  • the myth of a conflict-free community, noting that disagreement is a natural part of collaboration.

  • the need for leaders to develop skills in navigating tension while maintaining relationships.

[00:21:20] Conditions for Successful Communities

  • key factors that contribute to thriving communities, including a strong catalyst for engagement, a sense of shared purpose, and an environment where members feel valued.

[00:23:03] The Importance of Bridging Capital in Building Inclusive Networks

  • the difference between bonding capital (connections within like-minded groups) and bridging capital (connections across diverse perspectives).

  • while bonding capital is abundant, we need to strengthen our capacity for bridging across differences.

[00:26:24] Lessons from the Past: Can We Rebuild Community Engagement?

  • Drawing from Robert Putnam’s research (Bowling Alone), James and Carol reflect on historical cycles of social cohesion and fragmentation.

  • They discuss the potential for a resurgence in civic engagement and the role nonprofits can play in facilitating it.

[00:33:10] Rethinking Association and Nonprofit Models

  • Challenging the traditional association model, arguing that many are more focused on providing benefits than fostering true community.

  • shifting from a transactional membership model to a more experiential, impact-driven approach.

[00:37:45] Designing Organizations for Connection and Problem-Solving

  • how nonprofits and associations can be more intentional in creating environments that prioritize deep engagement.

  • A vision for a future where associations move beyond serving industries and professions to solving larger societal challenges.

[00:41:28] Invitation to Nonprofit Leaders: Permission to Forgive Ourselves

  • James offers nonprofit leaders a permission slip to let go of unrealistic expectations and recognize the limits of their individual impact.

  • He emphasizes the importance of sustaining energy for the long haul and remembering that meaningful change happens incrementally, through collaboration.

Key Takeaways for Nonprofit Leaders

  1. Embrace a Beginner’s Mindset – Expertise is valuable, but curiosity and openness to new perspectives are essential for innovation.

  2. Strengthen Bridging Capital – True community-building requires reaching across silos to engage with those outside of our usual circles.

  3. Create Conditions for Trust and Engagement – Design intentional spaces where people can come together around shared challenges and solutions.

  4. Shift from Transactions to Transformation – Associations and nonprofits should move beyond offering “stuff” to creating meaningful, shared experiences.

  5. Pace Yourself for Impact – Avoid burnout by acknowledging that systemic change takes time and collective effort.

Guest Bio:
James Young is founder and chief learning officer of the Product Community and writes a weekly newsletter called The Innovative Association. Jim is a leading thinker in the worlds of associations, learning communities, and product development. Prior to starting the product community, he served as senior vice president for education and chief learning officer at the American College of Chest Physicians and chief learning officer at the Society of College and University Planning. He earned a PhD at George Mason University, a masters at the University of Michigan, and a bachelors at Michigan State University.

Important Links and Resources:

James Young

Product Community

Byers Young Group

Bowling Alone

The Upswing

Join or Die

Related Episodes:

Episode 117 - Grounded presence for nonprofit leaders in chaotic times

Episode 100 - 10 things I have learned about nonprofits

Episode 95 - Building shared nonprofit leadership

Episode 75 - Confronting generational conflicts in nonprofits

LISTEN + SUBSCRIBE
APPLE PODCASTS SPOTIFY

Previous
Previous

Using AI for better nonprofit fundraising with Josh Hirsch

Next
Next

Ethical video storytelling for nonprofits with Rachel Jellinek